It is finally the weekend after what felt like the longest week ever for no real reason at all. My kids and I were both out of school a few days the week prior – due to Irma’s storm path and power outages – so maybe that interruption threw us off a bit. For whatever reason, it’s been hard to keep the rhythm and forward motion this week.
I flew through JD Vance’s Hillbilly Elegy last week on Audible. (As a side note, this year marks the first time ever that I’ve had a kid-free commute as a working mom, and I am loving it! Catching up on audiobooks and podcasts makes it fly by and feel like a bit of an indulgence instead of a chore.) There are a lot of varying opinions on this book, and it’s received a ton of criticism. It has its weaknesses, no doubt. But on the whole, I loved it so much, and it won’t leave me alone – which is the best measure of a book well written. I’ve been tumbling its scenes and lines in my head ever since I finished it, and it will stay with me a long time.
It essentially tells the story of a man not much younger than I am who grew up poor in Appalachia and is now a Yale-educated lawyer. There is a lot in between those two pieces, and therein lies the story. There were things that I related to as a southerner, and there were things that seemed like far-reaching generalizations that were nothing at all like my own childhood. But I think it is a brave and unflinchingly honest look at his own family and at the difficulties of rising from one social class to another.
He makes it clear that were it not for his Mamaw and Papaw, as the calls them, he wouldn’t be where he is today at all. Though the personality of his feisty Mamaw could not be farther from my gentle Grandmother, I share that common thread of owing much of who I became to my grandparents.
Vance tells us about his grandparents’ insistence that he work hard to rise above his current place in life and that “Mamaw often told a parable: A young man was sitting at home when a terrible rainstorm began. Within hours, the man’s house began to flood, and someone came to his door offering a ride to higher ground. The man declined, saying, ‘God will take care of me.’ A few hours later, as the waters engulfed the first floor of the man’s home, a boat passed by, and the captain offered to take the man to safety. The man declined, saying, ‘God will take care of me.’ A few hours after that, as the man waited on his roof—his entire home flooded—a helicopter flew by, and the pilot offered transportation to dry land. Again the man declined, telling the pilot that God would care for him. Soon thereafter, the waters overcame the man, and as he stood before God in heaven, he protested his fate: ‘You promised that you’d help me so long as I was faithful.’ God replied, ‘I sent you a car, a boat, and a helicopter. Your death is your own fault.’ God helps those who help themselves. This was the wisdom of the Book of Mamaw.”
That was the wisdom of the Book of My Grandparents as well – that God helps those who help themselves. It’s a concept I continue to think about, and I can trace that line to where I am now. I still think I have a ways to go, and I know that it is entirely up to me where I end up. My final destination is up to my own stubborn ambition and determination to help myself – and to the choices I make and the karma I create which follows all of us eventually.
I’ve always believed it was a combination of fate and choice that gets you where you are, and this just gets clearer and more defined for me as I steer my own ship now – a privilege I never really had until I was 33 years old and fate pushed me off that seemingly comfortable boat into some rough waters that have smoothed out now to give me more space and freedom than I’ve ever had.
Something strange is happening these past few months where instead of seeing this season of my life as a storm to weather, I’m feeling its very best pieces passing so quickly that I’m a little scared to let them go one day. My main fear, as I wrote about a few weeks ago after the Jen Pastiloff workshop, is that I won’t finish the work I know I’m meant to do because I drown in the little things. I know this season I’m in is ripe for my own ambitions, and I guess the challenge is to hold onto that even when life moves me to another page. This season might be one for my own ambitions, but it’s also ripe for drowning in the responsibilities of single parenting, and I feel that, too. My intentions and ideas are clearer than ever, but unfortunately, my pace is more frenzied than ever as well.
My kids have this thing about sleeping in my bed. If they had their choice, they’d be there every night, but they are getting bigger, and it just gets too crowded, so I bribed them a year or two ago with a sticker chart and a grand prize of a 5 dollar bill to get them out. It worked for the most part, but they still beg or use any special occasion (Mom, I had a fever today, so I need to sleep in your bed, right?) as an excuse to sleep there. It’s not that I even care all that much, but I just sometimes want some tiny piece of the day to be mine, some tiny space in this house to be mine. I try to limit the indulgence when I can.
But Jude read some ghost story last week that completely frightened him worse than I have ever seen, and every bit of it was real to him. You could tell by the way he described it and the expression he wore when he was telling me. He begged to sleep with me, and I said yes – which of course elicited It’s unfair! tears from sister, so there we all were. All three of us huddled in my bed with the last blaze of September heat outside my window, heavy heads and limbs all over me all night long. Three nights in a row last week.
I feel like this is the dance we constantly do over here. Sometimes it is me pushing them away for a little freedom and sometimes it is them doing the same to me. We are all trying to spread our wings a little wider and needing one another to give us space, but then also needing each other a little closer sometimes. I think that is the magic sauce in any good relationship – to give that person space to breathe and be but also be willing to drop everything to listen and just be there when you’re needed.
In Hillbilly Elegy, Vance tells us about his sister’s tears when his Papaw died, how she suddenly felt that she’d taken advantage of him. What he said when reflecting on that is something that will stay with me for a long time: “To this day, being able to ‘take advantage’ of someone is the measure in my mind of having a parent. For me and Lindsay, the fear of imposing stalked our minds, infecting even the food we ate. We recognized instinctively that many of the people we depended on weren’t supposed to play that role in our lives, so much so that it was one of the first things Lindsay thought of when she learned of Papaw’s death. We were conditioned to feel that we couldn’t really depend on people—that, even as children, asking someone for a meal or for help with a broken-down automobile was a luxury that we shouldn’t indulge in too much lest we fully tap the reservoir of goodwill serving as a safety valve in our lives.”
My kids see me as a bottomless reservoir, and I know this for certain. It is the thing that drives me crazy sometimes. That feeling like an invisible stagehand as I’ve written about before. The one packing the lunches and washing the ballet tights and checking off the homework charts that no one else in the world sees at all. But it’s still my greatest privilege and my greatest responsibility.
I’m writing and planning and dreaming in tiny pockets of time when I can. But for now, it still feels like the three of us here and the whole world out there – waiting for me to find it when I can.
6 thoughts on “bottomless reservoir”
I have been reading your posts for several years and have always been impressed with the authenticity and honesty of your writing. At this point in your life it is to be expected that loving and supporting your family is your priority. You might not realize how many people you have impacted in a positive way through your writing. We all experience loss, pain, and suffering. Hopefully we also all experience love, happiness, and connection. Your writing touches on the universal but does so from a very personal perspective. I am a 50 year old man who has been happily married for over 30 years and I find your writing incredibly inspiring.
A couple of books I would like to recommend. You might have mentioned the first one at some point Man’s Search for Meaning by Viktor Frankl. I have found this helpful in my own search for meaning. Also My Struggle by Karl Ove Knausgaard, this is a 6 volume autobiographical novel. Having made it through the first 3 I feel this is a masterpiece. I don’t have enough time to even begin to describe this novel.
You are destined to write either a great novel or memoir. In the meantime keep being your awesome self and keep writing.
Thank you so much for this comment, Joe. Both the reading recs and the encouragement to keep writing. I’ve begun work on a book proposal for a memoir, but it’s slow going with the demands of motherhood. I’m about 10,000 words in now, but the hardest part is writing my way into the scope of the book itself – exactly how I will link certain events of my life together. I think it’ll take a while to come together, but I feel sure it will happen one day.
It is the very best compliment and assurance for me when I hear from a reader who comes from a very different life or situation than I do but still comes here to read about the aspects of our lives that are universal. I just looked a bit at your reading recommendations and both look fascinating. I’ll tackle Frankl’s book this fall sometime and Knausgaard when I can. (Just read a NY Times review on him and what an innovative idea. Wow. Definitely piqued my curiosity.)
Thanks so much for taking the time to read and to leave this comment. I love getting book recs from readers!
A mutual friend of ours says she doesn’t like “The Giving Tree” because she feels like the tree with her kids . It never occurred to me to dislike that book, just a reminder to appreciate when people give themselves to you. Though I get that appreciation doesn’t come from children at a young age. I do believe one day they will grow to understand and appreciate, but is a long term investment. Your “Bottomless Reservior” reminds me of that sweet tree.
Always love to read your work.
I’d never made that association with The Giving Tree, but I can see that. It does make you feel all spent up sometimes. It’s a long term investment for sure. Everyone grows up to “get it” one day, but they just don’t get it yet. I guess that’s the definition of childhood though. If they did understand sacrifice, they’d always walk around feeling they owed me. Childhood means no worries, but that means mom carries all the worries herself.
Wow. This is absolutely eerie! I am just finishing this book right now!! How can this be? 🙂 I’m sure you read so much more than me, but we somehow seem to be on a very similar literary wavelength! You’ve recommended books that I’ve loved and I’ve found myself on websites and podcasts that you mention time and time again. It’s the first non-spiritual book I’ve read in a very long time and I have been captivated by his writing and his story. So timely to hear your take on it right as I am reading it. Thanks for sharing your thoughts and your story.
So crazy, Monica! We are always running across the same things. It’s not a perfect book; I thought it got a little preachy and political at the end. But on the whole, I did love it – especially the raw honesty about his childhood and the truths he shares about how it even continues to shape him now.